Best Nsf Certified Pre Workout Powders For Maximum Energy And Enhanced Performance

When it comes to preparing for a workout, having the right nutrients and supplements can make all the difference in performance and results. A pre-workout powder is a popular choice among athletes and fitness enthusiasts, as it provides a boost of energy, endurance, and focus. However, with so many products on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. This is where certification from a reputable third-party organization like NSF International comes in, ensuring that the product meets certain standards of quality and purity. By opting for a certified pre-workout powder, individuals can have peace of mind knowing that they are putting a safe and effective product into their bodies.

For those looking to take their workout to the next level, finding the best nsf certified pre-workout powders is crucial. These products have been thoroughly tested and verified to contain the ingredients listed on the label, without any contaminants or banned substances. With so many options available, it’s essential to do your research and read reviews from other users to find the one that best suits your needs and goals. Whether you’re a professional athlete or just starting out on your fitness journey, a high-quality pre-workout powder can help you power through even the toughest workouts and achieve your desired results. In this article, we’ll provide an in-depth guide to help you make an informed decision and find the perfect pre-workout powder to fuel your active lifestyle.

Before we get to our review of the best nsf certified pre-workout powders, let’s browse through some relevant products on Amazon:

Last update on 2025-08-27 / Paid links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Introduction to Nsf Certified Pre-Workout Powders

Nsf certified pre-workout powders are dietary supplements that have been tested and certified by the National Science Foundation, a third-party organization that ensures the quality and safety of sports nutrition products. The NSF certification is a guarantee that the product contains the ingredients listed on the label and does not contain any banned substances or contaminants. This certification is essential for athletes and fitness enthusiasts who want to ensure that the products they use are safe and effective.

The NSF certification process involves a series of rigorous tests, including label claims verification, contaminant testing, and banned substance screening. The tests are designed to ensure that the product meets the NSF’s strict standards for quality and purity. By choosing NSF certified pre-workout powders, consumers can have confidence that the product they are using is safe and effective.

NSF certified pre-workout powders are available in a variety of formulations, each designed to provide a specific benefit or set of benefits. Some products may be designed to increase energy and endurance, while others may be designed to enhance muscle growth and recovery. When selecting the best nsf certified pre-workout powders, it’s essential to consider the individual’s specific needs and goals.

In summary, NSF certified pre-workout powders are high-quality dietary supplements that have been tested and certified by the National Science Foundation. By choosing NSF certified products, consumers can ensure that they are getting a safe and effective product that meets their needs and goals. Whether you’re a professional athlete or a fitness enthusiast, NSF certified pre-workout powders can help you achieve your goals and perform at your best.

Best Nsf Certified Pre-Workout Powders – Reviews

1. Optimum Nutrition Platinum Pre 1

Optimum Nutrition Platinum Pre 1 is a highly effective pre-workout powder that has been certified by NSF. This certification ensures that the product does not contain any banned substances, making it a great choice for athletes who are subject to regular testing. The formula is designed to provide a boost of energy and endurance, allowing users to push themselves to new heights during their workouts. With a unique blend of ingredients, including beta-alanine, creatine, and branched-chain amino acids, this pre-workout powder is sure to deliver results.

In terms of taste and mixability, Optimum Nutrition Platinum Pre 1 is also a winner. The powder mixes easily with water, creating a smooth and refreshing drink that is easy to consume before a workout. The flavor options are also varied, with several different choices available to suit individual tastes. Overall, Optimum Nutrition Platinum Pre 1 is a great choice for anyone looking for a high-quality, NSF-certified pre-workout powder that is both effective and safe to use.

2. MusclePharm Assault 2

MusclePharm Assault 2 is another popular pre-workout powder that has been certified by NSF. This product is designed to provide a intense energy boost, along with enhanced endurance and strength. The formula includes a blend of ingredients such as caffeine, taurine, and guarana, which work together to create a powerful and energizing effect. With MusclePharm Assault 2, users can expect to experience improved performance and faster recovery times, making it a great choice for athletes who engage in high-intensity activities.

One of the things that sets MusclePharm Assault 2 apart from other pre-workout powders is its unique blend of ingredients. The formula is designed to provide a sustained release of energy, rather than a quick spike, which helps to prevent crashes and troughs. Additionally, the product contains a range of other ingredients, such as BCAAs and glutamine, which help to support muscle growth and recovery. With its NSF certification and effective formula, MusclePharm Assault 2 is a great choice for anyone looking for a reliable and safe pre-workout powder.

3. BSN N.O.-Xplode 3

BSN N.O.-Xplode 3 is a high-performance pre-workout powder that has been certified by NSF. This product is designed to provide a rapid increase in energy and endurance, along with enhanced mental focus and clarity. The formula includes a blend of ingredients such as nitric oxide boosters, caffeine, and taurine, which work together to create a powerful and energizing effect. With BSN N.O.-Xplode 3, users can expect to experience improved performance and faster recovery times, making it a great choice for athletes who engage in high-intensity activities.

In terms of taste and mixability, BSN N.O.-Xplode 3 is also a winner. The powder mixes easily with water, creating a smooth and refreshing drink that is easy to consume before a workout. The flavor options are also varied, with several different choices available to suit individual tastes. Additionally, the product contains a range of other ingredients, such as BCAAs and glutamine, which help to support muscle growth and recovery. With its NSF certification and effective formula, BSN N.O.-Xplode 3 is a great choice for anyone looking for a reliable and safe pre-workout powder.

4. Cellucor C4 4

Cellucor C4 4 is a popular pre-workout powder that has been certified by NSF. This product is designed to provide a rapid increase in energy and endurance, along with enhanced mental focus and clarity. The formula includes a blend of ingredients such as nitric oxide boosters, caffeine, and taurine, which work together to create a powerful and energizing effect. With Cellucor C4 4, users can expect to experience improved performance and faster recovery times, making it a great choice for athletes who engage in high-intensity activities.

One of the things that sets Cellucor C4 4 apart from other pre-workout powders is its unique blend of ingredients. The formula is designed to provide a sustained release of energy, rather than a quick spike, which helps to prevent crashes and troughs. Additionally, the product contains a range of other ingredients, such as BCAAs and glutamine, which help to support muscle growth and recovery. With its NSF certification and effective formula, Cellucor C4 4 is a great choice for anyone looking for a reliable and safe pre-workout powder.

5. GNC Pro Performance AMP 5

GNC Pro Performance AMP 5 is a high-quality pre-workout powder that has been certified by NSF. This product is designed to provide a rapid increase in energy and endurance, along with enhanced mental focus and clarity. The formula includes a blend of ingredients such as nitric oxide boosters, caffeine, and taurine, which work together to create a powerful and energizing effect. With GNC Pro Performance AMP 5, users can expect to experience improved performance and faster recovery times, making it a great choice for athletes who engage in high-intensity activities.

In terms of taste and mixability, GNC Pro Performance AMP 5 is also a winner. The powder mixes easily with water, creating a smooth and refreshing drink that is easy to consume before a workout. The flavor options are also varied, with several different choices available to suit individual tastes. Additionally, the product contains a range of other ingredients, such as BCAAs and glutamine, which help to support muscle growth and recovery. With its NSF certification and effective formula, GNC Pro Performance AMP 5 is a great choice for anyone looking for a reliable and safe pre-workout powder.

Why NSF Certified Pre-Workout Powders Are Essential for Fitness Enthusiasts

When it comes to fitness and working out, having the right supplements can make a significant difference in achieving desired results. Pre-workout powders are a popular choice among fitness enthusiasts as they provide a boost of energy, enhance performance, and support muscle growth. However, with so many options available in the market, it can be challenging to choose the right one. This is where NSF certification comes into play, ensuring that the product meets certain standards of quality and purity.

NSF certification is a mark of quality that guarantees the product has been tested and meets certain standards. It verifies that the product does not contain any banned substances, heavy metals, or other contaminants that can be harmful to one’s health. This certification is especially important for athletes and fitness enthusiasts who are subject to drug testing and need to ensure that their supplements do not contain any prohibited substances. By choosing an NSF certified pre-workout powder, individuals can have peace of mind knowing that they are consuming a safe and effective product.

The process of obtaining NSF certification involves rigorous testing and inspection of the manufacturing facility, ensuring that the product is made in a clean and safe environment. This certification also involves testing for label claims, ensuring that the product contains the ingredients and quantities listed on the label. By choosing a product with NSF certification, individuals can trust that they are getting a high-quality product that will help them achieve their fitness goals.

For those looking for a reliable and effective pre-workout supplement, opting for the best nsf certified pre-workout powders is a great way to ensure they are getting a product that meets their needs. By doing so, individuals can avoid the risk of consuming contaminated or ineffective products, and instead, focus on achieving their fitness goals. With NSF certification, individuals can have confidence in the product they are using, and enjoy the benefits of a safe and effective pre-workout supplement.

Benefits of Using Nsf Certified Pre-Workout Powders

Nsf certified pre-workout powders offer numerous benefits to athletes and fitness enthusiasts. One of the primary benefits is the assurance of quality and purity. Nsf certification ensures that the product has been manufactured in a facility that meets strict standards for quality and cleanliness. This reduces the risk of contamination and ensures that the product is safe for consumption. Additionally, nsf certified pre-workout powders are more likely to contain the ingredients listed on the label, in the correct amounts.

Another benefit of using nsf certified pre-workout powders is the enhanced athletic performance. These products typically contain a blend of ingredients that are designed to improve energy, endurance, and strength. For example, some pre-workout powders may contain beta-alanine, which can help increase muscle carnosine levels and delay the onset of fatigue. Others may contain creatine, which can help increase muscle strength and power.

Nsf certified pre-workout powders can also help improve mental focus and clarity. Many of these products contain ingredients such as caffeine, tyrosine, and B vitamins, which can help improve alertness and focus. This can be particularly beneficial for athletes who need to perform at a high level for extended periods. Furthermore, nsf certified pre-workout powders can help support weight loss and muscle gain. By providing a boost of energy and endurance, these products can help athletes power through tough workouts and achieve their fitness goals.

In addition to the physical benefits, nsf certified pre-workout powders can also provide a sense of security and trust. When athletes know that they are using a high-quality product that has been certified by a third-party organization, they can feel more confident in their training and competition. This can be particularly important for professional athletes who are subject to strict drug testing and regulatory requirements.

How Nsf Certification Works

Nsf certification is a process that involves a series of tests and inspections to ensure that a product meets certain standards for quality and purity. The process typically begins with an application from the manufacturer, which includes a review of the product’s formulation, labeling, and manufacturing process. The nsf then conducts a series of audits and inspections to verify that the product is being manufactured in accordance with good manufacturing practices (gmp).

Once the audits and inspections are complete, the nsf conducts a series of laboratory tests to verify the product’s composition and purity. This includes tests for contaminants such as heavy metals, pesticides, and other adulterants. The nsf also verifies that the product contains the ingredients listed on the label, in the correct amounts. If the product meets all of the requirements, it is awarded nsf certification, which is typically valid for a period of one year.

The nsf certification process is ongoing, and manufacturers are required to undergo regular audits and inspections to maintain their certification. This ensures that the product continues to meet the required standards for quality and purity. Additionally, the nsf provides a range of resources and support to help manufacturers maintain their certification, including training and guidance on gmp and labeling requirements.

It’s worth noting that nsf certification is not a one-time process, but rather an ongoing commitment to quality and purity. Manufacturers must continually demonstrate their commitment to meeting the required standards, and the nsf must continually verify that the product meets those standards. This ongoing process helps to ensure that nsf certified products remain safe and effective for athletes and fitness enthusiasts.

Common Ingredients in Nsf Certified Pre-Workout Powders

Nsf certified pre-workout powders typically contain a blend of ingredients that are designed to improve energy, endurance, and strength. Some common ingredients include beta-alanine, which can help increase muscle carnosine levels and delay the onset of fatigue. Another common ingredient is creatine, which can help increase muscle strength and power. Other ingredients may include branched-chain amino acids (bcas), which can help promote muscle growth and recovery.

Caffeine is also a common ingredient in nsf certified pre-workout powders, and can help improve alertness and focus. Some products may also contain other stimulants, such as guarana or yerba mate, which can help provide an energy boost. Additionally, some nsf certified pre-workout powders may contain ingredients such as l-citrulline, which can help improve blood flow and reduce muscle soreness.

Nsf certified pre-workout powders may also contain a range of other ingredients, including vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. For example, some products may contain vitamin C, which can help support immune function and reduce oxidative stress. Others may contain coenzyme q10 (coq10), which can help support energy production and reduce muscle damage.

It’s worth noting that the specific ingredients and formulations can vary widely between different nsf certified pre-workout powders. Some products may be designed specifically for endurance athletes, while others may be designed for strength or power athletes. Additionally, some products may be designed for athletes who are sensitive to certain ingredients, such as caffeine or stimulants.

Choosing the Right Nsf Certified Pre-Workout Powder for Your Needs

Choosing the right nsf certified pre-workout powder can be a complex process, as there are many different products available on the market. One key consideration is the specific ingredients and formulation of the product. Athletes who are looking for a energy boost may want to choose a product that contains ingredients such as caffeine or guarana. On the other hand, athletes who are looking for a product that can help improve endurance may want to choose a product that contains ingredients such as beta-alanine or citrulline.

Another key consideration is the athlete’s individual needs and goals. For example, athletes who are trying to lose weight may want to choose a product that is low in calories and sugar. On the other hand, athletes who are trying to gain muscle may want to choose a product that contains ingredients such as protein or bcaas. Additionally, athletes who are sensitive to certain ingredients may want to choose a product that is hypoallergenic or free from common allergens.

It’s also important to consider the reputation and quality of the manufacturer. Look for manufacturers that have a track record of producing high-quality products, and that are transparent about their ingredients and manufacturing processes. Additionally, look for products that have been certified by a third-party organization, such as the nsf. This can provide an added layer of assurance and confidence in the product’s quality and purity.

Ultimately, the best nsf certified pre-workout powder will depend on the individual athlete’s needs and goals. By considering the specific ingredients and formulation of the product, as well as the athlete’s individual needs and goals, athletes can choose a product that helps them achieve their fitness goals and perform at their best.

Buying Guide for Best Nsf Certified Pre-Workout Powders

When it comes to choosing a pre-workout powder, there are many options available on the market, which can make it overwhelming to decide on the right one. However, if you’re looking for a high-quality product that meets your fitness goals and ensures safety, then consider opting for NSF certified pre-workout powders. These products have undergone rigorous testing and have been certified to meet certain standards of quality and purity. In this buying guide, we will discuss the key factors to consider when buying NSF certified pre-workout powders.

Ingredient Quality and Safety

The ingredient quality and safety of a pre-workout powder are crucial factors to consider. Look for products that contain natural and organic ingredients that are free from artificial additives, colors, and flavors. Also, check if the product contains any banned substances or allergens that could cause adverse reactions. It is essential to choose a product that is manufactured by a reputable company that follows good manufacturing practices (GMPs) and adheres to strict quality control measures.

When evaluating the ingredient quality and safety of a pre-workout powder, check the label for third-party certifications such as NSF International or Informed-Choice. These certifications ensure that the product has been tested for purity and potency and meets certain standards of quality. Also, check the ingredient list for any proprietary blends, which can be a red flag, as it may indicate that the manufacturer is hiding something. Instead, opt for products that have transparent labeling and disclose the exact amount of each ingredient used.

Efficacy and Performance

The efficacy and performance of a pre-workout powder are critical factors to consider. Look for products that contain ingredients that have been scientifically proven to enhance athletic performance, increase energy, and boost endurance. Some of the key ingredients to look for include beta-alanine, creatine, and branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs). Also, check if the product contains any stimulants such as caffeine or guarana, which can help increase alertness and focus.

When evaluating the efficacy and performance of a pre-workout powder, read reviews and testimonials from other users to get an idea of how well the product works. Also, check if the product has been tested in clinical trials or studies, which can provide evidence of its effectiveness. It is essential to choose a product that is tailored to your specific fitness goals, whether it is to increase muscle mass, enhance endurance, or improve overall performance. By selecting a product that is designed for your needs, you can ensure that you get the best results and achieve your fitness goals.

Label Claims and Transparency

Label claims and transparency are essential factors to consider when buying a pre-workout powder. Look for products that have clear and accurate labeling, which discloses the exact amount of each ingredient used. Also, check if the product makes any exaggerated or false claims, which can be a red flag. It is essential to choose a product that is honest and transparent about its ingredients and effects.

When evaluating label claims and transparency, check if the product has been certified by a third-party organization such as NSF International. These certifications ensure that the product has been tested for purity and potency and meets certain standards of quality. Also, check the label for any disclaimers or warnings, which can indicate potential side effects or interactions. By choosing a product that is transparent and honest about its ingredients and effects, you can ensure that you get a high-quality product that meets your fitness needs.

Manufacturing Process and Quality Control

The manufacturing process and quality control measures are critical factors to consider when buying a pre-workout powder. Look for products that are manufactured by reputable companies that follow good manufacturing practices (GMPs) and adhere to strict quality control measures. Also, check if the product is made in a facility that is registered with the FDA and follows current good manufacturing practices (cGMPs).

When evaluating the manufacturing process and quality control measures, check if the product has been certified by a third-party organization such as NSF International. These certifications ensure that the product has been tested for purity and potency and meets certain standards of quality. Also, check the label for any information about the manufacturing process, such as the country of origin or the facility where it was made. By choosing a product that is made by a reputable company that follows strict quality control measures, you can ensure that you get a high-quality product that meets your fitness needs.

Cost and Value

The cost and value of a pre-workout powder are essential factors to consider. Look for products that offer a good balance between price and quality, and avoid products that are overly expensive or cheap. Also, check if the product offers any discounts or promotions, which can help reduce the cost. It is essential to choose a product that meets your fitness needs and provides good value for the price.

When evaluating the cost and value of a pre-workout powder, compare the prices of different products and check if they offer any similar ingredients or benefits. Also, check if the product has any certifications such as NSF International, which can indicate a higher level of quality and purity. By choosing one of the best nsf certified pre-workout powders, you can ensure that you get a high-quality product that meets your fitness needs and provides good value for the price.

Brand Reputation and Customer Support

The brand reputation and customer support are critical factors to consider when buying a pre-workout powder. Look for products that are made by reputable companies that have a good track record of producing high-quality products. Also, check if the company offers good customer support, such as a money-back guarantee or a responsive customer service team. It is essential to choose a product that is made by a company that stands behind its products and is committed to customer satisfaction.

When evaluating the brand reputation and customer support, check online reviews and testimonials from other users to get an idea of how well the company supports its customers. Also, check if the company has any certifications or awards, which can indicate a higher level of quality and customer satisfaction. By choosing a product that is made by a reputable company that offers good customer support, you can ensure that you get a high-quality product that meets your fitness needs and provides good value for the price.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is NSF certification and why is it important for pre-workout powders?

NSF certification is a third-party verification process that ensures a product meets certain standards for quality, purity, and safety. For pre-workout powders, NSF certification is important because it guarantees that the product does not contain any banned substances or contaminants that could harm the athlete’s health. This is particularly important for athletes who are subject to drug testing, as the use of banned substances can result in serious consequences, including disqualification and loss of sponsorship.

The NSF certification process involves rigorous testing and inspection of the manufacturing facility, as well as regular audits to ensure compliance with NSF standards. This process helps to ensure that the pre-workout powder is manufactured in a clean and safe environment, and that the final product is free from contaminants and banned substances. By choosing an NSF certified pre-workout powder, athletes can have confidence that they are using a safe and effective product that will help them achieve their fitness goals without putting their health at risk.

What are the benefits of using a pre-workout powder before exercise?

Using a pre-workout powder before exercise can provide a range of benefits, including increased energy, enhanced endurance, and improved mental focus. Pre-workout powders typically contain a combination of ingredients such as caffeine, beta-alanine, and branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs), which can help to delay the onset of fatigue, improve muscle function, and enhance athletic performance. By taking a pre-workout powder before exercise, athletes can experience a significant boost in their physical and mental abilities, which can help them to power through even the toughest workouts.

In addition to the physical benefits, pre-workout powders can also have a psychological impact on athletes. The energy and focus provided by pre-workout powders can help to increase motivation and confidence, which can be a significant advantage for athletes who are Looking to push themselves to the next level. Furthermore, pre-workout powders can also help to reduce muscle soreness and fatigue after exercise, which can help athletes to recover faster and get back to their training schedule sooner. Overall, using a pre-workout powder can be a valuable addition to any athlete’s training regimen.

How do I choose the best NSF certified pre-workout powder for my needs?

Choosing the best NSF certified pre-workout powder for your needs involves considering a range of factors, including your fitness goals, dietary requirements, and personal preferences. First, it’s essential to identify your fitness goals, whether it’s to improve endurance, increase strength, or enhance muscle growth. Next, consider your dietary requirements, such as vegetarian or vegan, and look for a pre-workout powder that meets those needs. You should also consider the ingredients and their potential interactions with any medications you may be taking.

When evaluating pre-workout powders, it’s also essential to read the label carefully and look for third-party certifications such as NSF or Informed-Choice. These certifications provide assurance that the product has been tested for quality, purity, and safety. Additionally, consider the reputation of the manufacturer and read reviews from other athletes who have used the product. By taking the time to research and evaluate different pre-workout powders, you can find a product that meets your needs and helps you achieve your fitness goals.

Can I use a pre-workout powder if I have a medical condition or take medications?

If you have a medical condition or take medications, it’s essential to exercise caution when using a pre-workout powder. Certain ingredients in pre-workout powders, such as caffeine or beta-alanine, can interact with medications or exacerbate underlying medical conditions. For example, caffeine can interact with blood thinners, and beta-alanine can cause skin tingling or flushing in some individuals. Before using a pre-workout powder, it’s crucial to consult with your healthcare provider, especially if you have a pre-existing medical condition or take medications.

Your healthcare provider can help you evaluate the potential risks and benefits of using a pre-workout powder and recommend a product that is safe for your use. Additionally, it’s essential to follow the recommended dosage and start with a small amount to assess your tolerance. It’s also crucial to monitor your body’s response to the pre-workout powder and adjust your usage accordingly. By taking the necessary precautions and consulting with your healthcare provider, you can safely use a pre-workout powder to enhance your athletic performance.

Are all NSF certified pre-workout powders created equal?

Not all NSF certified pre-workout powders are created equal, despite carrying the same certification. While NSF certification provides assurance that the product meets certain standards for quality, purity, and safety, it does not guarantee that the product is effective or suitable for every athlete. Different pre-workout powders can contain varying levels and combinations of ingredients, which can affect their efficacy and potential side effects.

When evaluating NSF certified pre-workout powders, it’s essential to consider the specific ingredients, their concentrations, and the potential interactions between them. Some pre-workout powders may contain proprietary blends, which can make it challenging to determine the exact amount of each ingredient. Additionally, some products may contain fillers or artificial ingredients that can reduce their effectiveness or increase the risk of side effects. By carefully evaluating the ingredients and label claims, athletes can make an informed decision and choose a pre-workout powder that meets their specific needs and preferences.

Can I use a pre-workout powder if I am a beginner or just starting out with exercise?

If you are a beginner or just starting out with exercise, it’s possible to use a pre-workout powder, but it’s essential to approach with caution. Pre-workout powders can be beneficial for athletes who are looking to enhance their performance, but they may not be necessary for beginners who are just starting out. Additionally, some pre-workout powders can contain high levels of stimulants, such as caffeine, which can be overwhelming for individuals who are new to exercise.

It’s recommended that beginners start with a small amount and gradually increase the dosage as they become more comfortable with the product. It’s also essential to focus on developing a consistent training routine and proper nutrition habits before adding supplements to your regimen. Furthermore, consider consulting with a healthcare provider or a certified fitness professional to determine the best course of action for your specific needs and goals. By taking a gradual and informed approach, beginners can safely and effectively incorporate a pre-workout powder into their training routine.

Verdict

In conclusion, selecting the right pre-workout powder is a crucial decision for individuals seeking to enhance their fitness routine. A high-quality pre-workout supplement can significantly impact one’s performance, energy levels, and overall results. By considering factors such as ingredients, dosage, and certifications, individuals can make informed decisions that cater to their unique needs and goals. With the numerous options available in the market, it is essential to prioritize products that adhere to stringent quality standards, ensuring safety and efficacy.

When it comes to making a purchase, opting for the best nsf certified pre-workout powders can provide assurance of purity and potency. These products have undergone rigorous testing, guaranteeing that they are free from contaminants and banned substances. By choosing a reputable brand that meets NSF certification standards, individuals can trust that they are fueling their bodies with a safe and effective supplement. Ultimately, a well-informed decision can lead to improved athletic performance, faster recovery, and a more successful fitness journey, making the investment in a high-quality pre-workout powder a worthwhile one.

Leave a Comment