Tired of the same old black and brown mascaras? Burgundy mascara offers a sophisticated and universally flattering alternative, adding a touch of subtle warmth and dimension to your lashes. Whether you’re aiming for a soft, romantic look or a bolder, statement-making eye, the right shade of burgundy can elevate your makeup game. But with so many options on the market, finding the absolute best burgundy mascara can feel like a daunting task. That’s where our comprehensive guide comes in.
We’ve scoured reviews, tested formulas, and consulted with beauty experts to bring you the ultimate rundown of the best burgundy mascaras available. From volumizing and lengthening to defining and conditioning, we’ll delve into what makes each product stand out, helping you navigate the shades and finishes to find your perfect match. Get ready to discover the mascaras that will transform your lashes and unlock a new level of lash enchantment.
Before we get to our review of the best burgundy mascara, let’s browse through some relevant products on Amazon:
Last update on 2025-08-27 / Paid links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
What is Burgundy Mascara?
Burgundy mascara is a unique and often overlooked shade in the world of lash enhancers. Moving beyond the traditional black and brown, burgundy mascara offers a subtle yet impactful way to add depth and intrigue to your eye makeup. It falls into the category of colored mascaras, but with a sophisticated and wearable hue that can complement a wide range of eye colors and skin tones.
The appeal of burgundy mascara lies in its ability to enhance the natural warmth of the eyes. For those with blue or green eyes, burgundy can create a striking contrast, making their eye color pop. For brown eyes, it adds a rich, multidimensional tone that can be more interesting than a standard brown mascara. It’s a versatile shade that can transition seamlessly from daytime elegance to evening allure, offering a touch of unexpected color without being overly bold.
Choosing the best burgundy mascara depends on your desired effect. Some formulas offer a subtle tint for a barely-there enhancement, while others provide a more intense, pigmented finish. Whether you prefer lengthening, volumizing, or defining, there are burgundy mascara options available to suit your lash needs and aesthetic preferences. Exploring different formulations will help you discover the perfect match for your personal style.
Incorporating burgundy mascara into your makeup routine is a simple yet effective way to elevate your look. It’s a fantastic option for anyone looking to experiment with color in a sophisticated manner, and finding the right formula can truly transform your lashes and draw attention to your eyes.
Top 5 Best Burgundy Mascara
1. L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara in Mystic Burgundy
This mascara is a true gem for anyone looking to add a touch of subtle drama and warmth to their lashes. The shade “Mystic Burgundy” is a beautiful deep berry with hints of red, making it universally flattering. It applies smoothly, coating each lash without clumping, and the brush is perfectly shaped to capture even the shortest lashes, providing excellent separation and definition. The formula is lightweight and doesn’t feel heavy throughout the day.
What truly sets this mascara apart is its ability to create a sophisticated, yet noticeable, lash look. It’s not an overly bright or theatrical color, but rather a sophisticated hue that can be worn for everyday elegance or for a more impactful evening look. The wear time is impressive, with no flaking or smudging, and it’s surprisingly easy to remove.
2. Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara in Burgundy Brown
Maybelline has done it again with this fantastic burgundy mascara. The “Burgundy Brown” shade is a perfect blend of rich brown with a clear burgundy undertone, offering a softer alternative to black mascara while still providing noticeable definition. The unique flexi-tip brush is designed to reach every lash from root to tip, delivering incredible length and volume without any stiffness or spidery effect.
This mascara is excellent for creating a lifted and fanned-out lash look, reminiscent of a sky-high impact. It lengthens beautifully, giving the illusion of fuller and longer lashes. The formula is smudge-proof and long-lasting, and the deep color adds a beautiful richness to the eyes, making them appear brighter and more awake.
3. Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara in Very Black Brown
While technically not a pure burgundy, Covergirl’s “Very Black Brown” offers a deep, rich brown with subtle warm undertones that many will find reminiscent of a muted burgundy. It’s a fantastic option for those who want a departure from traditional black but aren’t ready for a bolder hue. The signature Lash Blast brush is known for its ability to build volume quickly and effectively, coating lashes generously.
This mascara delivers impressive volume and thickness, making lashes appear fuller and more dramatic. It’s a great everyday mascara that adds a touch of depth without being overpowering. The formula is generally long-wearing and doesn’t typically flake, making it a reliable choice for daily use.
4. Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara in Burgundy Brown
Essence continues to impress with its affordable yet high-quality mascaras, and this burgundy option is no exception. The “Burgundy Brown” shade is a lovely, deep reddish-brown that adds a subtle yet noticeable warmth to the lashes. The conic-shaped fiber brush is designed to provide both length and volume, creating a dramatic “false lash” effect.
This mascara excels at lengthening and thickening lashes, giving them a full and fluttery appearance. It coats lashes evenly and without clumping, offering a beautiful fanned-out look. For its price point, the performance is outstanding, providing good wear time and a beautiful color payoff that enhances the eyes.
5. Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara in After Midnight
Ilia’s “After Midnight” mascara, while described as a deep brown, often has a subtle red or burgundy undertone that can be perceived as a very muted burgundy, especially on lighter lashes. It’s an incredibly clean beauty option formulated with nourishing ingredients. The dual-sided brush is designed to both lengthen and lift lashes, providing definition and volume without any heaviness.
This mascara is celebrated for its ability to create naturally defined and lifted lashes. It separates beautifully, coating each lash evenly without clumping. The formula is buildable, allowing for a subtle daytime look or more dramatic evening volume. Its clean ingredients make it a fantastic choice for sensitive eyes, and the subtle warm undertones add a touch of sophistication.
Why Burgundy Mascara is a Must-Have
Burgundy mascara offers a sophisticated and subtly alluring alternative to traditional black or brown. It adds a unique depth and warmth to the lashes, enhancing the natural color of your eyes without being overly dramatic. This rich, wine-inspired shade can make green, hazel, and even lighter brown eyes appear more vibrant and captivating. It’s a fantastic way to experiment with color in a way that feels universally flattering and adds a touch of refined elegance to any makeup look, from everyday wear to special occasions.
The appeal of burgundy mascara lies in its ability to create a soft, romantic effect. Unlike bolder colored mascaras that can sometimes look costume-like, burgundy strikes a perfect balance between noticeable and natural. It can subtly emphasize the length and volume of your lashes while imbuing them with a hint of warmth and mystery. This makes it an excellent choice for those who want to step outside the black mascara box but prefer a more understated approach to makeup experimentation.
Furthermore, burgundy mascara is incredibly versatile. It transitions seamlessly from daytime to evening, adding a touch of unexpected flair without drawing too much attention. It pairs beautifully with a wide range of eyeshadow colors and lipstick shades, from soft neutrals to deeper berries. For those seeking the best burgundy mascara to elevate their beauty routine, it’s a product that offers a sophisticated upgrade to the lash game.
Ultimately, people are drawn to burgundy mascara for its ability to offer a subtle yet impactful enhancement. It’s a way to express personal style and embrace a touch of unconventional beauty that feels both chic and approachable. The unique color provides a flattering warmth that can make the eyes pop in a way that’s both elegant and memorable, making it a worthwhile addition to any makeup collection.
Why Choose Burgundy Mascara?
Burgundy mascara offers a subtle yet sophisticated alternative to traditional black or brown formulas. Its rich, warm tones can enhance a variety of eye colors, adding depth and intrigue without being overly dramatic. For those looking to experiment with color in a wearable way, burgundy provides a beautiful spectrum of shades, from deep wine to brighter berry tones, allowing for personalization and a unique makeup statement.
This particular shade is incredibly versatile, making it a fantastic choice for both everyday wear and special occasions. It can soften the look of the lashes, making them appear fuller and more defined, while also complementing a wide range of eyeshadow looks and lipstick shades. If you’re tired of the same old mascara routine, burgundy presents an exciting opportunity to refresh your makeup bag and elevate your overall aesthetic.
Beyond its aesthetic appeal, burgundy mascara can also be a great option for those with fair skin or lighter eye colors who find black mascara too harsh. It provides definition and impact without the stark contrast, resulting in a more natural and harmonious look. Experimenting with burgundy can unlock a new level of confidence and expressiveness in your makeup choices.
How to Style Your Burgundy Mascara
Styling burgundy mascara involves embracing its unique color to create captivating eye looks. For a subtle enhancement, pair it with neutral eyeshadows like taupe, champagne, or soft browns. A single coat on the upper lashes can add definition and a hint of color that subtly draws attention to your eyes, making it perfect for a professional or everyday setting.
To amp up the drama, don’t be afraid to explore bolder eyeshadow pairings. Deep purples, plums, or even a touch of metallic bronze can create a stunning contrast with burgundy mascara, making your eyes truly pop. Consider a subtle smoky eye where the burgundy mascara acts as the focal point, or use it to complement a jewel-toned eyeshadow for a more adventurous vibe.
Don’t forget the versatility of layering. You can start with a black mascara for ultimate volume and definition on the base of your lashes, and then sweep a burgundy mascara over the tips. This technique creates a multi-dimensional effect, showcasing the rich burgundy hue as the lashes move and catch the light.
Understanding Burgundy Mascara Shades
The world of burgundy mascara isn’t a one-size-fits-all affair; it encompasses a diverse range of shades, each offering a unique effect. From deep, almost black cherry tones that provide a hint of color in certain lighting to brighter, more vibrant berry shades that make a statement, understanding these nuances is key to finding your perfect match.
Consider your natural eye color when selecting a burgundy shade. Deep, wine-like burgundies can beautifully enhance blue and green eyes, adding warmth and intensity. For brown eyes, a more reddish-brown or brick-toned burgundy can create a striking, complementary effect, making them appear richer and more captivating.
Texture and finish also play a role. Some burgundy mascaras offer a matte finish, providing a sophisticated and subtle color payoff. Others come with a subtle shimmer or metallic sheen, which can catch the light and add a touch of glamour, perfect for evening looks. Exploring these different finishes will help you achieve the desired impact for your makeup.
Tips for Application and Removal
Achieving the best results with burgundy mascara starts with proper application. Begin by curling your lashes to create a lifted base. Then, apply the mascara from the root to the tip of your lashes, wiggling the wand back and forth to ensure even coating and separation. For added intensity, you can apply a second coat, but be mindful of clumping.
When aiming for a more natural look, focus on applying mascara only to the upper lashes, or just a light dusting on the tips of the lower lashes. If you desire a more dramatic effect, a second or even third coat can be applied, but ensure you use a mascara wand that effectively separates lashes to avoid a spider-leg appearance.
Removing burgundy mascara is just as important as applying it. Use a dedicated eye makeup remover, preferably one formulated for waterproof or stubborn formulas, to effectively break down the pigment without excessive rubbing. A gentle oil-based remover can also be very effective. Ensure all traces of the mascara are removed to prevent eye irritation and maintain lash health.
Your Ultimate Guide to Finding the Best Burgundy Mascara
Burgundy mascara offers a sophisticated and unique alternative to classic black or brown lashes, adding a touch of warmth and subtle drama to any makeup look. Whether you’re seeking a deep, wine-inspired hue or a brighter, berry-toned shade, selecting the right burgundy mascara can be a game-changer. This guide will walk you through the essential factors to consider, ensuring you find the perfect formula and shade to enhance your natural beauty and achieve your desired lash effect.
Shade Selection: Finding Your Perfect Burgundy
Burgundy isn’t a one-size-fits-all shade. It encompasses a spectrum of colors, from deep merlot and wine tones to brighter cherry and plum variations. Consider your natural eye color and skin undertone when choosing. For those with cooler undertones, berry-rich burgundies or plum-infused shades might be most flattering. If you have warmer undertones, a deeper, almost brick-red burgundy or a rich auburn-brown could be your ideal match. Swatching shades on your hand or a disposable wand is a great way to visualize how the color will appear before committing.
Ultimately, the “best burgundy mascara” for you will depend on the specific look you aim to achieve. Do you want a subtle hint of color that peeks through in certain lights, or are you aiming for a bold, statement lash? Some burgundies are so deep they can almost pass for black with a hint of warmth, while others are vibrant enough to be the focal point of your eye makeup. Experimentation is key, and don’t be afraid to try different shades until you discover the one that truly makes your eyes pop.
Formula and Finish: What Kind of Lashes Do You Desire?
Just like with traditional mascaras, burgundy formulas come in various finishes and offer different lash benefits. You might prefer a volumizing formula to create thicker, fuller lashes, or perhaps a lengthening mascara to elongate your lashes and give them a more dramatic appearance. Some formulas focus on curling, providing a beautiful lift without the need for an eyelash curler. Consider your natural lash type and what you want to enhance – are your lashes sparse and in need of volume, or are they short and begging for length?
The finish of the mascara is also important. Most burgundy mascaras offer a satin or semi-matte finish, which can appear more sophisticated and less harsh than a high-shine black mascara. However, some brands may offer a subtle shimmer or a more intense matte finish. Think about the overall aesthetic you’re going for. A slightly glossy finish can add a touch of elegance, while a completely matte finish might be preferred for a more understated daytime look. Reading reviews can also provide valuable insights into how a particular formula performs and its true finish.
Brush Design and Application: Precision and Ease
The wand or brush of your mascara plays a crucial role in how effectively you can apply the product and achieve your desired lash look. Different brush shapes are designed for specific purposes: cone-shaped brushes are excellent for reaching inner corner lashes and providing precise application; dense, bristled brushes are often best for building volume; and rubber or silicone brushes can excel at separating lashes and preventing clumps. For burgundy mascara, which can sometimes be more pigmented than black, a brush that ensures even distribution and separation is particularly important to avoid a muddy or clumpy appearance.
Consider your personal preference for application. Do you prefer a large, fluffy brush for quick, full coverage, or a slimmer, more precise brush for detailed work? If you’re new to colored mascaras or have smaller eyes, a smaller brush might offer more control and prevent accidental staining on your eyelids. The material of the brush (traditional bristles vs. silicone) can also affect how the mascara is dispensed and how it coats each lash. Ultimately, the brush should feel comfortable in your hand and allow for smooth, effortless application, letting you easily build up the burgundy color without mess.
Longevity and Smudge-Proofing: All-Day Wear
A key concern for any mascara user is its ability to withstand the day without smudging, flaking, or transferring to your eyelids. Burgundy mascaras, with their potentially richer pigments, can sometimes be more prone to showing up as dark marks if they smudge. Look for formulas that are explicitly labeled as long-wearing, smudge-proof, or transfer-resistant. Waterproof formulas offer the highest level of durability, but they can also be more difficult to remove at the end of the day, potentially leading to lash breakage if not handled with care.
When evaluating longevity, consider your daily activities. If you tend to have oily eyelids or live in a humid climate, a smudge-proof formula is essential. Reading customer reviews can offer real-world insights into how well a mascara holds up throughout the day, especially in different conditions. Some mascaras might start out great but begin to flake or smudge after a few hours, while others remain impeccable from morning to night. Paying attention to these details will help you find a burgundy mascara that keeps your lashes looking flawless all day long.
Ingredients and Lash Health: Nourishment and Care
Beyond color and performance, the ingredients in your mascara can significantly impact the health of your lashes. Many mascaras now include nourishing ingredients like vitamin E, panthenol (pro-vitamin B5), and various botanical extracts known to strengthen and condition lashes. If you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses, look for hypoallergenic and ophthalmologist-tested formulas, and avoid mascaras with harsh chemicals or strong fragrances.
For those concerned about lash thinning or breakage, a mascara with conditioning properties can be a valuable addition to your makeup routine. Ingredients like castor oil or keratin can help promote lash growth and resilience. While a burgundy mascara is primarily for aesthetic enhancement, choosing one that also cares for your lashes ensures you’re not compromising their health for the sake of color. Always check the ingredient list for any known allergens or irritants and prioritize formulas that aim to strengthen and protect your natural lashes.
Brand Reputation and Reviews: Trustworthy Choices
In the crowded beauty market, the reputation of a brand can be a good indicator of product quality and customer satisfaction. Established beauty brands often have a history of producing reliable formulas, and they may have more extensive research and development behind their products. However, don’t discount newer or indie brands that are making waves with innovative and high-performing mascaras. Exploring different brands can lead you to discover hidden gems and unique burgundy shades that you might not find elsewhere.
Customer reviews are an invaluable resource when making a purchasing decision. Websites, beauty blogs, and social media platforms are filled with honest opinions and experiences from people who have tried various burgundy mascaras. Look for reviews that discuss the specific aspects that are important to you, such as color payoff, formula consistency, longevity, and brush performance. Pay attention to both positive and negative feedback to get a well-rounded understanding of a product’s strengths and weaknesses, helping you make an informed choice to find your perfect burgundy mascara.
FAQ
What is Burgundy Mascara?
Burgundy mascara is a tinted mascara that offers a rich, deep red-brown hue. Unlike traditional black or brown mascaras, burgundy mascara provides a subtle yet noticeable color enhancement, adding a touch of warmth and depth to the lashes. It’s a versatile shade that can complement various eye colors and skin tones, offering a sophisticated alternative to standard mascara shades.
The appeal of burgundy mascara lies in its ability to make eyes “pop” without being overtly dramatic. It can create a softer, more natural-looking lash line than black mascara, while still defining and lengthening. For those with blue, green, or hazel eyes, burgundy can create a beautiful contrast, bringing out the richness of your natural eye color.
Who is Burgundy Mascara Best Suited For?
Burgundy mascara is a fantastic choice for individuals looking to subtly enhance their natural beauty or experiment with color without being too bold. It’s particularly flattering for those with fair to medium skin tones, as the warm undertones of burgundy can beautifully complement these complexions. People with hazel, brown, green, or even lighter blue eyes often find burgundy mascara enhances their eye color, making them appear more vibrant.
Furthermore, burgundy mascara is ideal for those seeking a sophisticated alternative to everyday black or brown. It’s perfect for transitioning from day to night, offering a touch of color that is both elegant and intriguing. If you have lighter hair colors or are simply looking to add a softer, more approachable look to your makeup routine, burgundy mascara is definitely worth considering.
How Do You Apply Burgundy Mascara?
Applying burgundy mascara is just like applying any other mascara. Begin by curling your lashes if desired, to open up your eyes and provide a better base for the mascara. Then, starting at the base of your upper lashes, wiggle the wand back and forth as you draw it up towards the tips. This technique helps to coat each lash evenly and build volume.
For a more intense look, you can apply a second or third coat, allowing each layer to dry slightly before applying the next. Pay attention to both the roots and the tips of your lashes for maximum impact. You can apply it to your lower lashes as well, but be sure to use a lighter hand to avoid a clumpy or overly dramatic effect.
What Are the Benefits of Using Burgundy Mascara?
One of the primary benefits of burgundy mascara is its ability to subtly enhance eye color. The warm, reddish tones can create a beautiful contrast with many eye colors, particularly hazel, green, and blue eyes, making them appear more vibrant and captivating. It offers a unique way to make your eyes stand out without the starkness of black mascara.
Beyond color enhancement, burgundy mascara provides the same lash-defining, lengthening, and volumizing benefits as traditional mascaras. It can frame the eyes, add definition to the lash line, and create a fuller, more dramatic lash look. It’s also a great option for those who find black mascara too harsh for their complexion or personal style, offering a softer yet still impactful alternative.
Can Burgundy Mascara Be Worn Every Day?
Absolutely! Burgundy mascara can be a fantastic everyday option for many people. Its subtle color adds a touch of warmth and definition that is far less intense than black mascara, making it suitable for professional environments or casual outings. It provides a sophisticated twist on a classic look without being overly attention-grabbing.
The key to wearing burgundy mascara daily is the intensity you choose to apply. A single coat can offer a natural enhancement, while multiple coats can build up the color for a more noticeable effect. It’s a versatile shade that can complement a wide range of makeup looks, from minimal to more elaborate, making it a practical choice for daily wear.
What Eye Colors Does Burgundy Mascara Best Complement?
Burgundy mascara is particularly flattering for eyes with warmer undertones or lighter shades. It creates a stunning contrast with blue eyes, making them appear brighter and more striking. For green eyes, burgundy can bring out golden and hazel flecks, making the green appear richer and more complex.
Hazel eyes often have a beautiful mix of brown, green, and gold, and burgundy mascara can enhance all of these tones, adding depth and warmth. Brown eyes can also benefit from burgundy mascara, as it can add a subtle reddish undertone that makes brown eyes appear deeper and more luminous, especially if there are any lighter flecks within the iris.
Where Can I Buy Burgundy Mascara?
You can find burgundy mascara at most major beauty retailers, both online and in physical stores. Popular beauty brands that offer burgundy or similar reddish-brown shades include Maybelline, L’Oréal, CoverGirl, and ColourPop, among many others. Specialty beauty stores like Sephora and Ulta Beauty are also excellent places to explore a wider range of brands and formulations.
For the most extensive selection and convenience, shopping online is often the best route. Websites of these retailers, as well as e-commerce giants like Amazon, will typically carry a variety of burgundy mascaras from different brands. Reading customer reviews on these platforms can also be very helpful in choosing a product that meets your specific needs for color, formula, and performance.
Final Verdict
Having explored the vibrant world of burgundy mascara, it’s clear that this rich, sophisticated hue offers a compelling alternative to traditional black and brown. From adding subtle warmth to creating a striking, eye-catching look, the right burgundy mascara can truly elevate your makeup artistry. We’ve dissected various formulations, finishes, and performance metrics to help you navigate the options and discover the product that best suits your individual lash type and desired aesthetic. Remember, the pursuit of the best burgundy mascara is a journey to unlock a new dimension of beauty, one that embraces color and commands attention with elegant flair.
Ultimately, the investment in a high-quality burgundy mascara is an investment in enhancing your natural beauty with a touch of unexpected charm. By considering the insights and recommendations presented, you’re well-equipped to make an informed decision that will leave your lashes looking fuller, longer, and beautifully tinted. Embrace the allure of burgundy and let your eyes do the talking with confidence, knowing you’ve chosen a product that promises both performance and panache, truly embodying the essence of the best burgundy mascara for your collection.