Unleash your inner artist and discover the vibrant world of crayon eyeshadow! These versatile makeup sticks are a game-changer for any makeup lover, offering effortless application, blendable formulas, and a spectrum of stunning shades to suit every mood and occasion. Whether you’re aiming for a subtle wash of color or a bold, smoky eye, crayon eyeshadows deliver creamy, pigmented payoff that lasts all day. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive deep into the top-performing crayon eyeshadows on the market, breaking down their unique features, wearability, and overall value to help you make the perfect choice.
Navigating the crowded beauty landscape to find the absolute best crayon eyeshadow can be a daunting task. With so many brands and formulations vying for your attention, it’s essential to have reliable information to guide your purchase. That’s where our expert reviews and in-depth buying guide come in. We’ve meticulously tested a wide array of crayon eyeshadows, evaluating everything from their pigment intensity and blendability to their longevity and creasing resistance. Get ready to elevate your eye makeup game with our curated selection and essential tips for achieving flawless looks every time.
Before we get to our review of the best crayon eyeshadow, let’s browse through some relevant products on Amazon:
Last update on 2025-08-27 / Paid links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
Crayon Eyeshadow: A Versatile Beauty Essential
Crayon eyeshadows have emerged as a beloved staple in makeup bags worldwide, offering a unique and user-friendly approach to eye color. Unlike traditional powder eyeshadows that require brushes and a bit more precision, crayon formulas glide effortlessly onto the lids, making them accessible to makeup enthusiasts of all skill levels. Their creamy texture allows for easy application, blending, and even lining, providing a versatile tool for creating a multitude of looks.
The convenience factor is a significant draw for crayon eyeshadows. They are perfectly portable, requiring no extra brushes or applicators, making them ideal for on-the-go touch-ups or travel. Whether you’re aiming for a sheer wash of color for a natural daytime look or building up for a more dramatic, smoky effect, the crayon format allows for intuitive control. This ease of use contributes greatly to their popularity, simplifying the makeup application process.
Beyond their ease of use, crayon eyeshadows often boast impressive staying power and blendability. Many formulations are designed to set quickly, preventing creasing and fading throughout the day. The creamy nature of the product also facilitates seamless blending, allowing you to soften edges and transition colors with ease. This makes achieving professional-looking results achievable even for beginners.
With a wide array of finishes, from matte to shimmer and metallic, and a spectrum of vibrant and subtle shades available, the search for the best crayon eyeshadow can lead to discovering a true makeup MVP. Their ability to function as eyeshadow, eyeliner, and even a base for powder shadow makes them an indispensable and multi-functional product in any makeup collection.
Top 5 Best Crayon Eyeshadow
1. NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil – Milk
This cult-favorite crayon eyeshadow in shade “Milk” is a true multitasker and a staple for any makeup bag. Its creamy, blendable formula glides on effortlessly, providing opaque white pigment that’s perfect for brightening the inner corners of the eyes, creating a cut crease, or as a base for bolder eyeshadow looks. The jumbo size makes application quick and easy, even for beginners, and it sets to a comfortable matte finish that lasts throughout the day without creasing.
Beyond its primary use as an eyeshadow, “Milk” also excels as a white eyeliner for that editorial pop or as a brow bone highlighter to lift and define. The affordability and versatility of this pencil are unmatched, making it an excellent value for the quality it delivers. It’s a reliable product that consistently performs, whether you’re going for a subtle enhancement or a dramatic statement.
2. Clinique Chubby Stick Shadow Tint for Eyes – Lots o’ Latte
“Lots o’ Latte” from Clinique’s Chubby Stick line is a sophisticated and universally flattering cream eyeshadow crayon. This shade offers a beautiful, subtle shimmer in a warm, taupe-brown hue that complements a wide range of skin tones. The formula is incredibly smooth and easy to blend, allowing you to build up the color intensity from a sheer wash to a more defined look. It dries down to a soft, satiny finish that doesn’t feel heavy or dry on the eyelids.
What sets this crayon apart is its long-wearing power and crease-resistant formula. You can apply it in the morning and trust that it will stay put for hours without fading or migrating into fine lines. It’s perfect for those busy days when you need a quick yet polished eye look that requires minimal fuss. The twist-up packaging also means no sharpening is necessary, adding to its convenience.
3. Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Colour – Amethyst
Laura Mercier’s Caviar Stick Eye Colour in “Amethyst” is a luxurious cream eyeshadow crayon that delivers stunning, multidimensional color. This particular shade is a gorgeous, deep plum with subtle violet and silver undertones that shimmer beautifully in the light. The formula is incredibly creamy and glides on like silk, making it exceptionally easy to apply and blend, even with just a fingertip. It can be worn sheer for a wash of color or layered for a more intense, smoky effect.
This caviar stick is a powerhouse when it comes to longevity and finish. It dries down to a semi-matte, velvety texture that is resistant to creasing and fading for a remarkable amount of time. The unique formula feels comfortable on the lids and adds a touch of opulence to any makeup look, making it ideal for special occasions or when you want to feel a little extra glam.
4. Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil – 601 Blacksmith
The Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil in “601 Blacksmith” is a versatile and high-performing cream eyeshadow crayon that doubles as a fantastic eyeliner. This shade is a deep, true black with a matte finish that provides intense pigmentation and exceptional staying power. Its creamy texture allows for smooth application, whether you’re creating a sharp, precise line or smudging it out for a smoky effect.
This pencil truly shines in its durability. It’s waterproof, transfer-proof, and smudge-proof once set, meaning your eye makeup will remain flawless throughout the day and night. “Blacksmith” is the perfect shade for creating dramatic winged liner, defining the lash line, or using as an all-over lid color for a bold, smoky eye. The precision tip makes it easy to control, and the formula is comfortable enough for all-day wear.
5. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil – Perversion
Urban Decay’s iconic 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in “Perversion” is a true testament to their reputation for long-lasting, intense color. This shade is a rich, velvety black with a matte finish that provides unparalleled pigment payoff. The “glide-on” nature of this pencil is no exaggeration; it applies smoothly and effortlessly without tugging or skipping, making it a dream to use.
What makes “Perversion” a standout is its incredible staying power. Once applied, it sets to a smudge-proof, waterproof finish that resists fading and creasing for up to 24 hours. It’s the perfect product for creating sharp, graphic looks or for a dramatic smoky eye that won’t budge. The creamy formula also makes it comfortable to wear along the waterline, offering intense definition without irritation.
The Colorful Appeal: Why You Need Crayon Eyeshadow
Crayon eyeshadow offers a unique and accessible way to explore color and creativity in makeup. Unlike traditional powder shadows, these pencils glide on smoothly, allowing for precise application and effortless blending. Whether you’re aiming for a subtle wash of color or a bold, graphic statement, crayon eyeshadow provides the versatility to achieve a wide range of looks without the need for multiple brushes or complex techniques. Their user-friendly nature makes them a fantastic option for makeup beginners and seasoned enthusiasts alike.
Beyond their ease of use, crayon eyeshadows are celebrated for their pigmentation and longevity. Many formulas are designed to be smudge-proof and crease-resistant, meaning your vibrant eye looks will stay put throughout the day or night. This durability is a significant advantage for those with busy lifestyles or who are attending events where touch-ups are not feasible. The creamy texture often allows for buildable coverage, enabling you to start with a sheer hint of color and layer it up for a more intense effect.
The convenience factor of crayon eyeshadow cannot be overstated. Their pencil form makes them incredibly portable, fitting easily into a makeup bag or clutch for on-the-go application or touch-ups. This makes them perfect for travel or for those moments when you want to switch up your look from day to night. The integrated applicator eliminates the need for separate tools, streamlining your makeup routine and saving you precious time.
For those seeking the best crayon eyeshadow, the market offers a dazzling array of shades and finishes, from matte to shimmering. Their versatility extends beyond just lids; many can be used as eyeliner or even as a vibrant base for powder shadows, enhancing their color payoff. This multi-functional aspect makes crayon eyeshadow a truly valuable addition to any makeup collection, offering endless possibilities for artistic expression.
Tips for Applying Crayon Eyeshadow Like a Pro
Crayon eyeshadow offers incredible versatility, but mastering its application can elevate your looks from simple to stunning. One of the most effective techniques is to use a primer beforehand. This creates a smooth canvas, preventing creasing and ensuring the crayon’s pigment stays vibrant throughout the day. A small amount is all you need; gently pat it over your lids before applying the crayon.
When it comes to application, don’t be afraid to experiment. For a sheer wash of color, lightly sweep the crayon across your lid and blend with your fingertip or a fluffy brush. For more intense color or a smoky effect, layer the crayon or use it directly on the lid and smudge with a brush or even your finger. You can also use the tip to define your lash line or inner corner for a pop of brightness.
Don’t forget the blending! The beauty of crayon eyeshadow lies in its blendability. Use a clean blending brush or a dense smudger brush to soften any harsh lines. You can also use a contrasting color to create depth and dimension. For a more dramatic look, consider using a darker shade in the crease and blending it outwards.
Exploring Different Finishes and Formulations
Crayon eyeshadows aren’t one-size-fits-all; they come in a delightful array of finishes that can dramatically alter the final look. You’ll find shimmery shades that catch the light beautifully, perfect for adding a touch of glamour. Matte finishes offer a sophisticated and velvety appearance, ideal for everyday wear or creating a subtle smoky eye.
Beyond the finish, the formulation itself plays a crucial role. Some crayon eyeshadows are exceptionally creamy and glide on with minimal effort, making them perfect for beginners or those who prefer a quick application. Others might be slightly firmer, offering more control for precise lines and detailed work. Consider whether you prefer a formula that sets quickly or one that remains pliable for longer, allowing you more time to blend.
The type of pigment and its intensity also vary. Some crayons are designed for a sheer, buildable color, allowing you to control the opacity. Others are highly pigmented, delivering full-coverage color in a single swipe. When choosing, think about the look you want to achieve. Do you want a subtle hint of color, or a bold, impactful statement? Reading reviews for specific products can give you a good idea of their true color payoff and blendability.
Maintaining and Storing Your Crayon Eyeshadows
To ensure your crayon eyeshadows last as long as possible and maintain their performance, proper storage is key. Always recap them tightly after each use to prevent the formula from drying out. Exposure to air can significantly shorten their lifespan and compromise their creamy texture. Store them upright in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight or extreme temperatures, as heat can cause them to melt or become too soft.
Regularly cleaning your crayons can also be beneficial, especially if you’re using them directly on your eyelids. Gently wipe the tip with a tissue or a makeup wipe after use to remove any excess product or potential bacteria. This helps maintain hygiene and prevents color contamination if you’re using multiple shades. For crayons that can be sharpened, keep your sharpener clean as well to ensure a sharp, precise point for application.
If you notice a crayon becoming a little too hard over time, a quick trick to revive it is to hold the tip over a warm (not hot) surface for a few seconds, like a warm mug. This can soften the wax and oils in the formula, making it glide more smoothly again. However, use this sparingly and be cautious not to overheat the product, as this can alter its texture permanently.
Pairing Crayon Eyeshadow with Other Makeup Products
Crayon eyeshadows are incredibly versatile and can be beautifully integrated into a full makeup routine. For a polished look, consider pairing your crayon eyeshadow with a good mascara to define your lashes and frame your eyes. A well-applied eyeliner, whether in pencil, liquid, or gel form, can further enhance the intensity of your crayon shadow, especially when used along the lash line.
The base you use can also significantly impact how your crayon eyeshadow performs. Applying a thin layer of primer or even a concealer before your crayon can help the color adhere better, prevent creasing, and make it more long-lasting. For a more vibrant pop, you can even use a white or nude base color before applying your crayon shadow, allowing the true pigment to shine through.
When it comes to blush and lipstick, think about the overall color story you want to create. If your crayon eyeshadow is bold and vibrant, opt for more neutral shades on your cheeks and lips to keep the focus on your eyes. Conversely, if you’re using a more subtle crayon shade, you can experiment with brighter blushes or lip colors to add personality and dimension to your overall makeup look.
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best Crayon Eyeshadow
Crayon eyeshadows have revolutionized the way we approach eye makeup, offering a versatile, user-friendly, and often long-lasting alternative to traditional powder shadows. Their creamy texture glides effortlessly onto the lids, making them ideal for both quick, everyday looks and more elaborate evening styles. Whether you’re a makeup novice or a seasoned pro, understanding the nuances of these convenient sticks can help you unlock their full potential. This guide will walk you through the essential factors to consider when selecting the perfect crayon eyeshadow to elevate your makeup collection.
Understanding Your Needs and Desired Finish
What kind of look are you aiming for?
Before diving into specific formulas and shades, it’s crucial to consider the desired finish and application. Do you prefer a subtle, satin sheen for a polished daytime look, or are you after a bold, metallic shimmer for a dramatic evening statement? Some crayon eyeshadows are designed to be blended out for a softer, diffused effect, acting as a primer or a wash of color. Others have a more opaque, defined application, perfect for graphic liner looks or precise application in the crease. Identifying your personal style and the occasions for which you’ll be using the product will significantly narrow down your options and ensure you’re investing in a crayon eyeshadow that truly complements your makeup routine.
Furthermore, think about the longevity you expect. Some crayon eyeshadows are formulated for extended wear, resisting creasing and fading throughout the day. If you have oily eyelids or are attending an event where your makeup needs to stay put, prioritizing long-wearing formulas is key. Conversely, if you enjoy experimenting with different looks throughout the day, a crayon that’s easily buildable and blendable might be more appealing, even if it means slightly less staying power. Considering these application and finish preferences from the outset will help you navigate the market more effectively and find a crayon eyeshadow that meets your specific needs.
Formula and Texture: Creamy vs. Waxy
How does the formula perform on your eyelids?
The core difference between various crayon eyeshadows often lies in their formula and texture. Some are incredibly creamy and blendable, gliding on like butter and allowing for easy manipulation on the lid. These are fantastic for achieving a diffused smoky eye or a soft wash of color. However, very creamy formulas can sometimes be prone to creasing or transferring if not set properly or if you have particularly oily eyelids. They often have a dewy or satin finish, which can be very flattering.
On the other hand, some crayon eyeshadows have a slightly waxier or drier texture. While they might require a bit more effort to blend, these formulas often offer superior staying power and a more matte or semi-matte finish. They are less likely to crease or smudge once set and can be an excellent choice for a base or primer, as they can help powder shadows adhere better and last longer. When choosing, consider your eyelid type and how you prefer your eyeshadow to feel and behave during application and throughout the day.
Pigmentation and Color Payoff
How vibrant and true to the pan is the color?
Pigmentation is a critical factor in any eyeshadow purchase, and crayon eyeshadows are no exception. You want a product that delivers rich, true-to-pan color payoff with minimal effort. Some crayon eyeshadows are sheer and buildable, allowing you to create a subtle hint of color or layer for more intensity. Others are highly pigmented from the first swipe, providing opaque coverage that can be dramatic and impactful. Consider the intended use: for a quick all-over lid color, high pigmentation is often desired for efficiency. For a more blended look, a slightly less intense pigment might offer more control.
When evaluating pigmentation, pay attention to how the color appears on your skin tone. A shade that looks stunning on one person might appear muted or different on another due to undertones. It’s always best to swatch shades on your arm or eyelid if possible. Additionally, consider the longevity of the pigment. Does the color fade or become patchy after a few hours? The best crayon eyeshadows will maintain their vibrancy and consistency throughout wear, ensuring your eye look remains impactful from morning to night.
Blendability and Ease of Application
How user-friendly is the crayon for creating different looks?
One of the biggest advantages of crayon eyeshadows is their inherent ease of application. They don’t require special brushes (though some can be enhanced with blending brushes) and can often be applied directly from the stick. However, the degree of blendability can vary significantly between products. Some crayons are designed to be smudged out immediately after application, allowing for quick smoky eyes or diffused color washes. Others set quickly, making them ideal for precise application as a liner or for a bold, graphic statement that doesn’t require blending.
When choosing, consider your skill level and the time you typically dedicate to your makeup. If you’re a beginner or prefer a quick application, a highly blendable crayon will be your best friend. If you’re comfortable with makeup techniques, you might appreciate a crayon that offers more precision and control, perhaps one that sets down to a budge-proof finish. Experimenting with different techniques, such as applying with a finger or a brush, can also enhance the blendability of a crayon eyeshadow, so don’t be afraid to play around to see what works best for you.
Longevity and Crease Resistance
How well does the crayon eyeshadow stay put throughout the day?
For many, the appeal of crayon eyeshadows lies in their potential for long-lasting wear. A great crayon eyeshadow should adhere well to the eyelid, resist creasing in the natural folds of the eye, and maintain its color intensity without fading or smudging. This is particularly important for those with oily eyelids, as eyeshadows can often break down or migrate more quickly. Formulas that set down to a more matte or semi-matte finish tend to offer better longevity and crease resistance.
When assessing longevity, consider whether the crayon eyeshadow works best on its own or as a primer. Some crayons are designed to be worn alone for a quick wash of color, while others excel as a base for powder shadows, enhancing their wear time and preventing creasing. Reading reviews and looking for claims of “long-wearing,” “crease-proof,” or “smudge-proof” can be helpful. If you have particularly persistent creasing issues, consider pairing your crayon eyeshadow with a good eye primer for maximum staying power.
Shade Range and Versatility
Does the range offer shades that suit your needs and skin tone?
The beauty of crayon eyeshadows is their versatility, and this often starts with the shade range. A well-curated selection of colors can cater to a wide array of preferences, from everyday neutrals to vibrant pops of color and deep, sultry tones. Consider what shades you typically reach for in your makeup routine. Do you prefer subtle mattes for a natural look, shimmering metallics for a glamorous touch, or bold, opaque colors to make a statement? A brand that offers a diverse range of finishes and hues will likely have a crayon eyeshadow that fits your personal style and makeup needs.
Beyond individual shades, think about the versatility of the crayon eyeshadow itself. Can it be used in multiple ways? For example, some crayons are pigmented enough to be used as a cream blush or lipstick in a pinch, or can be smudged out as an eyeliner. A crayon eyeshadow that offers multiple applications or can be layered with other products to create new shades adds significant value to your makeup collection. Evaluating the breadth of the color selection and the potential for creative, multi-purpose use will help you make a more informed purchase.
FAQ
What is crayon eyeshadow?
Crayon eyeshadow is a versatile makeup product that comes in a stick or pencil format, similar to a crayon. This format makes it incredibly easy to apply and blend directly onto the eyelids. Unlike traditional powder eyeshadows, crayon eyeshadows are typically formulated with waxes, oils, and emollients, giving them a creamy, smooth texture that glides on effortlessly.
The beauty of crayon eyeshadow lies in its portability and multi-functionality. They can be used as a single wash of color, as a base for powder eyeshadows to enhance their pigment and longevity, or even as a liner for a more dramatic look. Their mess-free application and often smudge-proof finishes make them a favorite for on-the-go touch-ups and for those who prefer a quicker makeup routine.
How do I apply crayon eyeshadow?
Applying crayon eyeshadow is remarkably simple and beginner-friendly. You can apply it directly from the stick onto your eyelid, either all over the lid for a wash of color or just to the crease for definition. For a softer, blended look, use your fingertip or a fluffy brush to gently smudge the edges before the product sets.
If you want to build up intensity or create a more complex look, you can layer different shades or use a crayon eyeshadow as a base. Apply a lighter shade all over the lid and then a darker shade in the crease or outer corner. Remember that many crayon eyeshadows set relatively quickly, so it’s best to work on one eye at a time and blend as you go to achieve the desired effect.
Are crayon eyeshadows long-lasting?
The longevity of crayon eyeshadows can vary depending on the specific formulation and your individual skin type and makeup application. However, many modern crayon eyeshadows are designed to be long-wearing and can last for several hours without creasing or fading, especially when used with an eyeshadow primer.
To maximize their staying power, ensure your eyelids are clean and free of oil before application. Using a primer can create a smooth canvas and help the crayon adhere better. For extra insurance, you can also set the crayon eyeshadow with a translucent powder or a matching powder eyeshadow to lock it in place throughout the day or night.
Can crayon eyeshadow be used as eyeliner?
Absolutely! The pointed tip of many crayon eyeshadows makes them excellent for use as eyeliner. You can draw a precise line along your lash line for definition, smudge it out for a smoky kohl effect, or even create winged liner looks.
The creamy texture of crayon eyeshadows allows for easy application along the lash line, and many are formulated to stay put without smudging or transferring. If you find the tip too thick for a sharp line, you can sharpen certain crayon eyeshadows with a dedicated makeup sharpener to create a finer point for more detailed work.
What are the benefits of using crayon eyeshadow?
The primary benefit of crayon eyeshadow is its ease of use and versatility. The stick format eliminates the need for brushes for basic application, making it perfect for travel and quick touch-ups. They offer a smooth, blendable application that can be built up for intensity or softened for a sheer wash of color.
Furthermore, crayon eyeshadows can serve multiple purposes in your makeup bag. They can act as eyeshadow bases to improve the performance of other shadows, as standalone eyeshadows for a quick pop of color, or as eyeliners for added definition. This multi-functionality makes them a practical and efficient choice for makeup enthusiasts of all skill levels.
How do I choose the right shade of crayon eyeshadow?
Choosing the right shade of crayon eyeshadow depends on your personal preference, the occasion, and your skin tone. For everyday wear, neutral shades like taupes, bronzes, and soft browns are universally flattering. For a more dramatic look, consider deeper shades like plums, deep greens, or blues.
Consider your eye color when selecting shades. For instance, warm tones like coppers and golds can make blue eyes pop, while purples and plums can enhance green eyes. If you have brown eyes, you have a wide range of colors that will look stunning, from bronzes to jewel tones. Don’t be afraid to experiment with different colors to discover what best complements your features.
How do I remove crayon eyeshadow?
Removing crayon eyeshadow is generally straightforward, especially if you use a good quality makeup remover. Start with a gentle micellar water or an oil-based makeup remover. Apply it to a cotton pad and hold it over your closed eyelid for a few seconds to allow the product to break down.
After allowing the remover to work, gently wipe across your eyelid. You may need to repeat the process a couple of times to ensure all traces of the crayon eyeshadow are removed, especially if it’s a long-wearing or waterproof formula. Follow up with your regular cleanser to ensure your skin is completely clean and free of any residue.
Final Thoughts
In your quest for captivating eyes, the “best crayon eyeshadow” offers an unparalleled blend of convenience, versatility, and performance. We’ve explored the top contenders, highlighting their unique strengths, from intense pigmentation and blendability to long-lasting wear and innovative formulations. Whether you’re a makeup novice seeking an effortless application or a seasoned artist looking for a reliable staple, the crayon eyeshadow format proves itself an indispensable tool for creating a myriad of looks, from subtle definition to dramatic flair. Investing in a high-quality crayon eyeshadow is an investment in your creativity and confidence.
Ultimately, the perfect crayon eyeshadow is one that complements your personal style and makeup routine. By considering the factors discussed – color payoff, wear time, ease of application, and skin type compatibility – you can confidently select a product that will become a go-to in your beauty arsenal. Embrace the ease and impact of crayon eyeshadow, and unlock a world of effortless beauty for any occasion.